Do you think the Osmond that passed to Hollywood is a legitimate Idol contestant?

[Lardawg]

I smell a set up. Guess who is already the American Idol for this season?

 

[LaurenM]

You know what I can't figure out is why people say they are planted, like that other girl who already had the record contract before...it's not like she became famous so really she still wants to be the american idol...but of course he is legitimate, he isn't famous and he hasn't made it yet