Reply to thread

Message: <blockquote data-quote="Palmo" data-source="post: 1601359" data-attributes="member: 623025">I have a year and a half doberman.  I can't get her to stop whining!!!  She whines for no reason at all it seems.  I have no idea how to get this to stop.  I've tried rewards when she doesn't whine, I've tried verbal disipline, I've tried pulling a pinch collar when she whines, and lastly (didn't want to but I'm desperate) I've tried shock collar.  She does quit when the shock collar is on but, when I take it off...... back to whining.  Please give me some suggestions.  Thanks in advance.I have taken her to the vet many times, deffinately not sick.</blockquote>