Toyota Rav4 verses... ?

[firefly1]

First car, preferences? Toyota Rav4, Honda CRV, or Jeep Liberty -- all probably 2005s.

I need 4WD, will be driving mostly around town rather than on the highway, gas mileage is definitely on my mind, and driving smoothness and driving feel is a top priority. Also, comfort and outward style is a big factor. Opinions?
** I need 4WD because I drive on a lot of dirt roads that you can't get through in the winter without 4WD.

 

[JustinM]

i'd go with the crv based on looks, but if you want good gas mileage and space id go with the rav4. jeep probably gets the worst gas mileage and theyre kinda ugly in my opinion.