Personally, i wouldnt go with either. Id go with Skullcandy. I have two pairs of them and have had them for years and they still give great sound, great bass, and a cool look. I have the Black Hesh over-ear headphones and the Ink'd earbuds. They're both pretty cheap to. The Hesh are about $60 at Target, and the Ink'd earbuds are only about $20 at the same place. You can also check out their website at www.skullcandy.com
Enjoy!