Where should we go on a romantic carribean vacation for our anniversary?

[tLorent]

My husband and I are planning a romantic vacation to the Caribbean for our 5th anniversary.
October 2011- Yes I'm starting to plan it a year and a half in advance.. I'm a planner

We want to go to an all inclusive resort. I want it to be romantic and somewhat secluded but would love to have some activities to keep us entertained as well. We're not golfers or tennis players...
Would love water sports like Jetskiing, Snorkling, Parasailing, swimming with dolphins maybe. I would exspecially enjoy shows or some form of entertainment.

Some places I have begun to cosider are:
The Bahamas, Turkes and Caicos, Virgin Islands, Antigua, Domincan Republic....

I orginally was fascinated by the Sandals Resort in Nassua, but now i'm thinking I would enjoy going somewhere a little less common and maybe a little further into the carribean.
My recent favorite is the Dreams resort in Punta Cana... any opinions on it?

Any and all suggestions are welcome, Thank You!!

 

[Kara]

what about Dominica?

 

[Bill]

We have spent most of our time in Jamaica and fine that Sandals in Negril and Breezes Grand Resort and Spa In Negril to be very romantic with tons of activities. To learn more check out the link below

 

[JohnCenafan2]

if not jamica go to the bahamas then