“Judas was a sinner – he just did the will of God to full fill prophecy.” Do...

He had the free will to choose not to, therefore, he was a sinner unless he asked forgiveness, which we don't know.
 
That is a good question.
I think though that though he did it it wasn't God's will. God knew it would happen though.
 
Whether he is a sinner only god knows.
No one suppose to play god to give judgment.
 
To say that God used Judas as a pawn is inaccurate.

It is acting like God created Judas just so he could betray Jesus and go to Hell forever.

In reality, God knew what type of person Judas would have been ANYWAY and decided to use him as a betrayer of Jesus because he would have ended up in Hell anyway.
 
It didn't have to be Judas who betrayed Jesus. It could have happened another way or through someone else if Judas had chose not to.
 
If god is the absolute source of morals and Judas was performing gods will, how could Judas sin?

Surely defying god's will would have been a sin.
 
Yup. Jesus was aware of Judas' intentions. If you believe in God, you believe in predetermination. No where at all does it state in the bible that we have freewill. Freewill is a philosophical concept introduced centuries after Jesus' death.
 
Judas' choices:

1) Betray Jesus, commit deicide.

2) Not betray Jesus, condemn all mankind to die in sin.

Either Judas had no free will or he just got plain screwed over by God.

Maybe he was a robot.
 
there was no judas! no jesus! no disciples! there was only paul, and all his material came from hallucinations and the religion he knew - mythology.

You think I'm kidding?
 
I do agree with you. Infact, what did happen was all but a play. To me, there was nothing sinful about that.That was the drama which repeats itself identically every 5000 years.
 
There were many possibilities and opportunities for Jesus to lay down his life for us. Scripture tells us of a few:

John 7:1
After this Jesus went about in Galilee; he would not go about in Judea, because the Jews sought to kill him.

Luke 20:19-20
The scribes and the chief priests tried to lay hands on him at that very hour, but they feared the people; for they perceived that he had told this parable against them. So they watched him, and sent spies, who pretended to be sincere, that they might take hold of what he said, so as to deliver him up to the authority and jurisdiction of the governor.

John 7:30-33
So they sought to arrest him; but no one laid hands on him, because his hour had not yet come. Yet many of the people believed in him; they said, "When the Christ appears, will he do more signs than this man has done?" The Pharisees heard the crowd thus muttering about him, and the chief priests and Pharisees sent officers to arrest him. Jesus then said, "I shall be with you a little longer, and then I go to him who sent me;

There are other verses as well but these are enough to demonstrate that Judas was not the only possibility. God's plan for salvation permitted Judas to be the instrument of betrayal. There is a lesson in this for us. Judas was a disciple. Likewise, we are disciples. Judas was blessed with grace and he even healed the sick and cast out demons with the rest of the apostles.

Likewise, we are blessed with grace. Like Judas, we can betray our Savior. All men are free to accept or reject God's grace. Grace enables but it does not force us. We must always put the Lord ahead of all things in our lives and never betray the Lord or the salvation that God has given us.
 
I always felt sorry for the character, I mean, he was just a pawn in a game, not his fault.

And how many people can honestly say that they've never done anything nasty to a mate? Yes he took it a bit far but hey, we all make mistakes.

He felt so guilty he killed himself, which in his mind meant hell. THAT shows how much he LOVED jesus surely.

Anyone who has a go at the guy is plain dumb really.

Edit: lol to the person that said simply "he disobeyed, he's a sinner"

Isn't that how kids reason?
 
God's will was for Christ to die on the cross, so that we could be forgiven. Judas could have not been to one to betray him. He has free will. However, his greed for money was far more important to him, then realizing that Jesus was one that could save Him. After Judas betrayed Jesus, he knew that he was wrong, and he took the money back, but was so guilt ridden that he hung himself. Jesus died for his sins as well as yours and mine- if he had come back to Jesus and asked for forgiveness, Jesus would have forgiven him and completely restored him. Look at the difference with Peter- Jesus knew that he would deny him 3 times before his crucifixion, and he did. Peter was devastated- however he did not kill himself- he went back to Jesus, repented and was completely restored.
 
Back
Top