That is up to the bouncer/security who is guarding the door.
Do you have a debit/credit card with the same name on the ID?
Since ID's can be faked, some clubs ask for that as well plus
most bouncers are off-duty cops so they know what to look for.
If your ID is legit, you will have nothing to worry about there.
http://411newyork.org/guide/2007/07/20/getting-access-to-nightclubs-in-new-york/