so Meyer based eclipse on brontes wuthering heights. honestly! wuthering heights was a great way but it left me feel cheated how heathcliff and catherine never got to live the life they wanted together. i also couldn't stand catherine because...i dont know what but she is a very fustrating and whiny.
speaking of whiny, bella was atrocious in eclipse (i dont mean to offend anyone. just like you twilighters, i do have an opinion). i think meyer was trying to put a bit of catherine in bella. which didn't work out. bella still remained a sook (no offense!).
bella vs catherine
while catherine and bella share some aspects and plots, where catherine was feisty and quick-tempered, bella was whimpy and whiny (which i think Meyer tried to make it look like it she had a temper, because everyone likes reading about a girl whose independent a quick-tempered. Meyer failed to do this. failed. miserably.
ps...edward sux! heathcliff rox!
speaking of whiny, bella was atrocious in eclipse (i dont mean to offend anyone. just like you twilighters, i do have an opinion). i think meyer was trying to put a bit of catherine in bella. which didn't work out. bella still remained a sook (no offense!).
bella vs catherine
while catherine and bella share some aspects and plots, where catherine was feisty and quick-tempered, bella was whimpy and whiny (which i think Meyer tried to make it look like it she had a temper, because everyone likes reading about a girl whose independent a quick-tempered. Meyer failed to do this. failed. miserably.
ps...edward sux! heathcliff rox!