Israel Blockades Lebanon

If only Israel's policy planners with nearly 60 years of experience surrounded by neighbours who want to destroy them had thought to hire a real expert (you) on how to deal with the situation.
 
I think we are talking about different things. Earlier in this thread people were saying that Saddam had to be removed because he has attempted to assassinate a sitting US President, despite the fact that the US has done the same thing several times.
 
No, we're talking about the same thing. I'm saying it's an attack on the US, and yes, the US has done the same thing.

But the argument "We can't respond to an attack on the US, because at other times we have attacked countries the same way" just doesn't make any sense.

There isn't a huge question on the morality of Saddam trying to assassinate an ex-President, it's just an attack that should be responded to.
 
Since you're advocating the Lebanese army's (hopefully) imminent taking over of the security situation in Southern Lebanon, it's totally relevant.

Aside from that, if you thought it was irrelevant why did you quote the question before your reply? To give the appearance of having answered?
 
It stinks of double standards, but if thats the case then fair enough, its not particularly surprising.
 
I dont think the Lebanese army would be as heavy handed as Israel have been. Afterall if the Lebanese army kill 20 children then they are going to be held accountable for it, whereas Israel will pull out their usual "We will investigate and find that we are not at fault" trick.
 
Double Standards?

It is fairly normal throughout the world to respond when your country gets attacked.


I don't understand this argument at all.

Since when does having attacked other countries in the past, mean we can't respond to attacks in the present?
 
Actually it the Lebanese governments idea not mine



Must have been an error on my part, don’t take it personally
 
I guess the question is, will they be able to maintain a less heavy handed approach and still hold the border?

Especially as it will be in Hezbollah's interests to alienate the Lebanese Army from the rest of the population using the same tactics they have against the Israelis.
 
This is a fascinating article about the Lebanon


Elaine Hagopian on Lebanon’s history of war and resistance

Why the U.S. and Israel wanted this war

http://www.socialistworker.org/2006-2/597/597_12_ElaineHagopian.shtml
 
Back
Top