This sounds like some confusion between, information, acumen and ability. The Presence has information. It is aware. It knows everything. That doesn't make it the smartest. Smart is defined as sharp quick thought. Which is an apt description of Batman, who no matter his quickness is still merely human. Still Lucifer Morning Star is a creature with extreme ability and power but does that mean he possess insight or judgement? We also have to question the insight and judgement of a being like Brainiac. He decided to be a criminal. Is that smart?
So that kind of leaves us with Superman. He is powerful, he has ability, he has acumen. But Supes does get spanked by Bats on a regular basis. This a puzzler.
What the heck, Wonder Woman.