Start Aaron Rogers or Michael Vick?

C

Critters

New member
Just dropped my second string and picked up Vick, but he played really well the little he did last week...better than rogers. Now he is starting this week. Should I stick with rogers and count on him to do better this week or start Vick?
 
M

MikeKunstle

New member
Start Rogers. Vick will start this week and it IS the lions, but I could never justify starting him over Rogers. He has proven himself a fantasy must start, and with jennings and J Finley, and more importantly NO grant you know the packers are going to pass a lot. Also, IMO vick had better than expected play because he was not expected to be an everydown QB. Even though the lions D is not that great they have had all week to scheme and will most likely blitz vick because when not able to run and has to make quick throws in the pocket he has horrible numbers.

End all be all, start rogers
 
N

nkpapageorgio

New member
Rodgers ALWAYS. I understand the temptation to start Vick but Detroit's been preparing for him all week as opposed to GB not expecting him to come in last Sunday. Don't let week #1 scare you off Rodgers will be the league's top scoring QB this year and you're lucky to have him
 
N

nkpapageorgio

New member
Rodgers ALWAYS. I understand the temptation to start Vick but Detroit's been preparing for him all week as opposed to GB not expecting him to come in last Sunday. Don't let week #1 scare you off Rodgers will be the league's top scoring QB this year and you're lucky to have him
 
R

Rob

Member
Rodgers was probably your first round pick...so you have to start him. BUT if you are smart, you would start vick against the lions...no stafford and terrible secondary and linebackers, Vick will light it up.
 
B

BeAfraid

New member
No offense but you are crazy if you don't start Rogers every week. Don't fall victim to the "one week syndrome." Not only does one week mean very little, but it was week 1. Rogers is going to explode against the Bills. Start him!

Good Luck!
 
A

ACeS

Member
Unless Vick shows consistency and match up against a weak D, start Rodgers regularly. He's a top round pick for a reason......
 
Top