What do you think is a greater honor for an NFL rookie?

Stacey

Member
Joined
May 26, 2008
Messages
147
Reaction score
0
Points
16
AP Rookie of the Year award, as voted on by sports writer, or.

Pepsi Rookie of the Year, as voted on by the fans?
 
AP. Sportswriters are professional at analyzing every aspect of the game, fans just see the good and bad from aj obvious standpoint .
 
Hmm...I'd probably have to say AP as fans can often buy into the hype. I know RG3 won the RotY according to whatever awar ESPN cares about...I wouldn't be surprised though if Luck won the other one simply bc he was more hyped over the season imo.
 
The fans voted for Wilson. He should have won ROY....He's better than RG3
 
Back
Top