Your dog should have been going outdoors all along. When do you walk your dog? I have two Min Pins that get their (15 - 20) minute walks every day. Plus, they are taken outdoors every couple of hours for "pee walks". You need to get into a routine and be consistent. For instance, if you feed in the mornings, wait about 20 mins. and put a leash on your dog and get her outside. Do this also, with her evening meal. If you are home during the day, do the same thing. I DO use the pee pads, but only on rare occasion. BTW, I have NEVER crated trained, but, understand it is the most effective way to house break a dog. Do some research and give it a try. Good luck! :}