Can you review my book concept? (Sci-fi with focus on human emotions)?

brian

Active member
Joined
May 13, 2008
Messages
1,070
Reaction score
0
Points
36
I used to make video games and this was one, however, it got rejected from some flash sponsors for involving suicide. I decided to write the story as a book instead. I am just starting.

I'm only 15 and barely read and write, so I might not be the most creative person... But I try! :D

---
A peaceful and idealist alien race comes down and oppresses humanity to try and get them to "calm their emotions." People including two protagonists (Glenn and Jonathan) escape with the help of an outside society. A group of rebels is forming in great strides but due to the harsh conditions the aliens placed on them, they arn't nescessarily rational. They raid the aliens to discover they worship a god and they try to maintain as much peace as possible. The humans get a slight emotional lapse (Very complicated) and decide to attack the aliens. They go through the city, slaughtering them all, but the aliens do not defend themselves. At the top of their governmental buildings a priest finally reveals their only intention was to aid the humans in sealing their emotions (Accomplished with PURE peace, without hatred, racism, ect) , which they did. Without anger, bravery, or selfishness they could not defend themselves and also failed to comprehend barbaric violence. However the peace is now disrupted as the aliens including the priest commit suicide and start going insane. The remaining aliens leave and it is hinted that they will destroy themselves through civil war.

The protagonists and resistance move to jerusalem for symbolic purposes, because it's the heart of human religious culture, and it's a place where selfishness was at it's peak, being conquered/reconquered over 20 times in history. They create a society emulating the aliens. The book ends with a kid (8 year old) being bullied at school, but not defending himself in anger. The teacher intervenes and takes him to somewhere unknown. The end.
---

Characters: (All protagonists, the focus shifts between them)

Glenn: Once a calm child after being detained he wallowed in misery and hatred and became a savage killing machine once he escaped. The leader of the alien massacre.

Jonathan: A placid teenager who decides that pacifism is the best way to resolve conflict however is stopped several times by the savages.

Miguel: A physicist that lived away from society when the aliens invaded, he organized the human rebellion against alien control. He has problems controlling the humans and reasoning between Glenn and Jonathan.

Please tell me if it at least sounds like a decent concept, I'm stressed out!
The symbolism is huge.

The aliens represent what could have been humanity, one of the shockers you find 1/3rd through is that they're structually similar to humans, rather, they have evolved.

Glenn represents evil, malice, and greed.
Jonathan represents compassion
And Miguel represents tolerance and balance.
@answerer

They're very religious, almost like a cult. They want the humans to conform and join them, since they're technically humans who have already suppressed emotion. It also follows their religious teachings.
 
I am confused. But, I don't have time to reread it to try to understand. I guess I don't really understand how the suppressing emotions thing works. The first thing It while reading it was WHY do the aliens want to help the humans? How to the aliens gain from this? - they're giving a lot for the humans but get nothing in return, it seems.
 
it sounds really good! i'm turning 16 in a few weeks and i'm really getting onto writing books and i have been for ever!! but its really tough, it seems like a great concept! if you've heard of Stephenie Meyer her book "The Host" was really cool and it had some of the things you mentioned too like aliens coming and controlling the hman race and then a rebel group trying to over throw them, its not as "kill-y" as yours seems but its definatly a good read and it made me want to write somehting like it i think you should definatly pick it up and read through it, and for sure keep going with your story! even if it doesnt end up published or anything at leats you will have it!! let me know it that helps!! -michaela :)

p.s. can you read my concept and tell me what you think?

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AuIPhE2XFfVeh9Fx4fJHozXsy6IX;_ylv=3?qid=20091114205201AAz9u0l
 
I really like it. I admit, some of it was a little confusing, like the emotional rift, but I assume you would explain that in greater detail in the book. Like I said, it was really good. I usually find aliens or robots unappealing, but find them in this case a symbol for something else, and really like it. The only thing I would change is the ending. Perhaps there is some symbolism in it that is explained in the book, but I can see where you going, but not totally understanding it. I think you should also use this as an allegory, with both the humans and the aliens representing different sides of human nature. If you need any help with the writing, I would love to offer my assistance.
 
Back
Top