Does Tim Tebow deserve Rookie of the Year instead of Sam Bradford?

[Ward]

Every time Tebow has been put in a game this year he has done nothing but score TDs. He is by far the more dynamic player on the field and the more moral person off the field. In his first start he has already run for a 40 yard TD. Do you think he deserves Rookie of the Year over Sam Bradford who had a terrible game, throwing no TDs and 2 interceptions today?

 

[michael]

Heck no! Bradford has turned the rams around into a better team and he will have a way better future than Tebow!

 

[mmzznnxx]

No, Bradford has been clearly better. Tebow hasn't even started until this week, and just scored one pass TD with a little luck and concentration from Lloyd.

Morality has nothing to do with Rookie of the Year, nor is it a measurable quality. The reason he only scores TD's is he's usually only put in at goalline situations.

He may or may not be the quarterback of the future, but there are multiple candidates who deserve it more than him; Bradford, Suh, Stevie Johnson, perhaps even Joe Haden.

 

[TimValencia]

Absolutely not. Tebow hasn't even played much this season, and Bradford has started every game thus far. Besides, I doubt Tebow will ever be a better QB than even Kyle Orton in the NFL while Bradford really looks like he's going to be special.

 

[HATEMALE]

oakland wasn't taking tebow seriously, once they wake up he will be shut down.

 

[Eric]

You can't be serious lol.

 

[KeithTucker]

Have Tebow start games first to put him in any categories

 

[whytey]

No, he hasn't played enough. Coming in during garbage time and getting your first start in the 14th week isn't enough, regardless of how well he plays. Bradford has started every game.