So for a few days my Android incredible phone wasn't working due to a frozen touch screen even after several times powering and removing the battery. Basically the phone still came on and would ring and buzz when I got sms, email, or calls but I couldn't get into the phone to view anything, answer calls or view/ respond to messages. I took phone to a Verizon store to get it checked out and they couldn't figure out a fix so they said I could get a free replacement phone since I was still under warranty. So the new phone comes and I activate it thus deactivating the old phone. When I put the battery back into the old phone to try to recover pics and data from the internal memory oh wow look, touch screen is working perfectly fine now. Verizon wants me to return the old phone (or else face charges for full retail price) which I am going to do today but will they charge me anything since the defect that I said the phone has is no longer there? Do I have a right to keep the new phone now that the old phone magically fixed itself?