Titanic (ok but average in my eyes)
The Lord of the Ring trilogy (ZZZZZZZ)
Gran Torino (ZZZZZZZZ)
Crash (overly dramatic and simplifies racism as if the audience is dumb)
Premonition (ok but people were raving as if Sandra Bullock and the script should win an Oscar... not so much)
Edit: I agree with DJ Styles, The Shawshank Redemption was very overrated. I watched it and instantly forgot about it. The Green Mile (both Stephen King film translations) is also overrated. I think people now believe Tom Hanks starring = Oscar worthy material.