Who is your offensive and Defensive rookie of the year?

F

Footballkid2

New member
Offense

Percy Harvin
Knowshon Moreno
Mohammed Massaquai
Pierre Garcon
Jermey Maclin
etc

Defense

Jarius Byrd
James Lauruenautis
Clay Matthews
Brian Cushing
Ray Maulaluga
Louis Delmas
etc
 
K

krazy_eye_killah

New member
Pierre Garcon isn't a rookie. Austin Collie is and for me it would be between Collie and Hakeem Nicks. Collie leads all rookie receivers in catches. He also has 7 tds and was picked WAY after all the other people you mentioned.

Defense has to go to Brian Cushing. My second choice would be Jarius Byrd and third would be Brian Orakpo.

You can't give anything to Harvin because he's missed too many games. Otherwise, he would be a shoe in.
 
H

hockeyplyr99

New member
Offense: Percy Harvin. He's been outstanding all year.

Defense: Tough one, but I'm going with Louis Delmas. He's really done great especially when you consider the crappy Lions defense that he was handed.
 
J

JL423

New member
Offense- Regardless of injury, Percy Harvin should be Offensive ROY. He leads all rookie WRs in yds, is tied for 2nd among rookie WRs in TD catches, & almost has over 1,000 kick return yds. He's been a true playmaker for the Vikings all yr long. The only other WRs who deserve it are either Austin Collie or Hakeem Nicks. Nicks averages 18 YPC this yr, along w/ 6 TDs

Defense- Its gotta be Cushing. Right now he's 6th in the ENTIRE NFL in tackles, & is tied for for 1st among all NFL LBs w/ 3 INTs. No rookie has made a bigger impact on D than Cushing. Jairus Byrd would get my 2nd place vote
 
Top