MLB 2K9 or MLB 09 The Show for PS2?

[baseballkid9836]

I have a playstation 2 and i am deciding on either getting MLB 2K9 or MLB 09 The Show which one should i get??

 

[gofish1985]

i know this guy who only plays mlb 09 the show he says its the best game ever

it looks good but its hard to play for me