The first person to accuse the Nazis of killing people in Soviet style gas...

...vans, was a sci-fi writer.......? At the Nuremberg trials, it was stated that the first reference to the gas-vans was from a sci-fi author.

"the mass extermination of people in gas vans was ascertained without reasonable doubt for the first time in the report of the Extraordinary State Commission on atrocities of the German occupiers in the Stavropol region. This document was submitted to the Tribunal by me earlier as Exhibit Number USSR-1 (Document USSR-1). Investigation of the crimes committed by the German fascists in the Stavropol region was directed by a prominent Soviet writer and member of the Extraordinary State Commission, Academician Alexey Nikolaevitch Tolstoy, who now is deceased."
http://avalon.law.yale.edu/imt/02-19-46.asp
___________

Soviets were using 'gas vans' long before the Nazis
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gas_van#Gas_vans_in_Soviet_Union
___________

Another relative said of Alexey Nikolaevitch Tolstoy:

"There was no lie, betrayal, or indignity which he would no hasten to commit in order to fill those empty pockets, and in Stalin he found a worthy master. Few families have produced a higher literary talent than Leo Tolstoy, but few have sunk to one as degraded as Alexei Nikolaevich."
- Nikolia Tolstoy
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aleksey_Nikolayevich_Tolstoy
___________

Did the Nazis get the idea from the Soviets, or did the Soviets just lie, again?
 

mmmmm

Member
Not sure of the point of this question. It seems quite possible but so what? Is it somehow better/worse to invent/copy an awful idea. Isn't there a matter of scale here? "Yeah I killed 6 million but I was just copying some one who killed even more" - not a great defence.
 

Chinacat

New member
Gas vans would have been remarkably inefficient.
The Nazis worshiped efficiency.
So it is unlikely the Nazis used gas vans.
 
Top