I can't agree. Neville is a plodder who only established his place because there were so few alternatives, and has now played so many times that he is considered indispensable due to his experience.
While he has had plenty of games where he hasn't done anything drastically wrong, he has made his fair share of defensive mistakes over the years. But his biggest weakness is that he offers so little going forward, and that just isn't good enough for a fullback at international level.
He was abysmal against Paraguay. Even against Jamaica he was poor, whereas Carragher looked twice as good as him once he switched to right back.