Trying to pick from a few unique girls interested in me; advice?

Aaron

Member
I'm at a crossroads in my life, and I have a lot of options in front of me... I'm trying to see the pros and cons of each choice. See, there are these four girls:

"H" - My girlfriend. We have a casual relationship, and things are peaceful. She's happy, and really cares for me. I don't care for her the way she does for me. I think she's a nice friend, but we don't have that spark, that passion. She doesn't have other social outlets aside from me, so she ends up just seeking my attention all the time. It's not a horrible thing to have a girl who loves you and wants to do everything to make you happy, but I'm interested in a partner, not a yes girl. She's not very strong or independent, and it repels me. She is currently seperated from her husband, for close to a year now.

"A" - My ex from work. We had a fling for a few months, that started while she was engaged to a guy who lived many states away. They were having problems, and he was becoming a little scary to her "You have to move here because I'm the man in the relationship, and your role is to obey me". She ended things with him, and we dated for a few months. Things were very passionate, but due to the circumstances surrounding the engagement, we were never able to be very public about it. It ended badly, and she spent the next several months apologizing to me. I eventually started speaking to her again. She's very flirty, and we have a lot of sexual chemistry and tension, a lot of flirty fun.

"L" - An ex from a few years ago, we had a fling for a few months. I ended it to pursue something more substantial with another woman. We've maintained a friendship over the years, and she recently had a baby girl, and is a single mom. We, too, had a lot of chemistry, and she's a very independent woman.

"S" - This woman is amazing. We're friends, and that's all. I bring her up because she's a really wonderful girl, and is sort of a measure of "perfect" for my situation here. She's an independent, intelligent, beautiful woman, that I would find myself in awe of being with.

My complicated situation is that the first three girls, my girlfriend, the ex from work, and the the single mom, all want to have a relationship with me. Not a casual fling, but pursue an real relationship. I don't feel very strongly for my girlfriend, and so I'm working to let her down gently. There's no reason to hurt her feelings, she really is a very nice person. From there, I don't know if I should pursue something with the ex from work with whom I share a lot of chemistry, but has messed me over before, the ex who is now a single mom, or neither. Neither would be the choice that goes something like, "I should be focusing on myself because neither of these girls are quality".

I seem to have very different standards than most, because a few people are pretty quick to dismiss everyone. They think the ex from work is, haha, "a little ho-ho" becuase she's flirting with me while I have a girlfriend, and we started relations while she was with her fiance. Easy to dismiss the single mom, too, because she may just be trying to latch on to some stability. Am I too relaxed with my standards? Does dating an ex who's now a single mom seem like I wasn't good enough in the first place, but am good enough now that she has baggage? Or should I be satisfied to have a girl who counts herself lucky to be with me, and learn to be content with someone who respects and loves me, but for whom I'm a little luke warm? I'm confused between my thoughts and my friend's advice....
EDIT: The last paragraph is an outline of the conflicting opinions I'm recieving from people, not really my thoughts. Her daughter is beautiful, and not in any way "baggage".

"S" isn't interested in me, she's just a high caliber person. And I agree that "H" deserves more. I ended it once before, explaining that my feelings weren't there and I felt guilty about it not going anywhere. She insisted I not worry about the future, because my feelings could grow, and just enjoy "today". I'm not enjoying today as much as I did, which is why I'm looking to end it with her.
 

Julia

Member
omg you're a f**king shallow pig....haha btw it spells hal-like shallow hal-get it?. lmao your choosing between women, when its obvious you think your gf is annoying. do her a favor and dump her. she doesnt need a whiny b*(#h like you. oh, your ex decided against you. i that rlly a screw up on her part? wasnt there a reason behind it? lmao of course she left. the reason you dont like nondominant girls is because you, yourself are completely futile to any relationship-you are the beta male. you have never made any srsly aggresive moves in you love life to make things happen. you need to either develop yourself more or freakin make a choice. but do everyone a favor. dump the gf. and btw, why would you include the perfect girl if its obvious you dont think you can get her? maaaybe you should actually try to get her, like a man would.
 

Indigo

Member
I suppose it depends on what you want from each and how serious you're willing to get.

If you can't pinpoint an event or issue that is causing you trouble with H and your feelings (or lack thereof) for her won't change, I agree that you should let her down gently. She sounds like a woman with a big heart, and I'm sure she'll be able to love someone else as much as she loves you. Let her find someone who will care for her with equal strength. It sucks to be at that end of a relationship that is unbalanced, emotionally.

I wouldn't try anything with A, for the reasons that others have already pointed out. I can't help but agree with them, from an objective standpoint. Flirty fun doesn't sound like the beginning of an appealing relationship to me...I like serious relationships, though. If another fling is what you're after, then by all means, go for it.

L probably is looking for security. Again, if serious is what you want, she's a good candidate, granted you're ok with the baby situation. My mom is a single parent, and security is the biggest priority of hers, dating-wise. She once said, "I own a house, a car, and I pay my own bills. A man better provide SOMETHING for me. I don't need a guy to fuck me, I have a vibrator". Something like that...the point is, I'm not sure she's what you're looking for, since you want a "partner" and there will probably be some degree of dependence on her part. She has a whole other being to care for, and she'll probably need at least a little help with that.

S sounds like a great option, but what is keeping you friends if she's so wonderful? Also, make sure you aren't leaving H just because you think something better (S) has come along.

Overall, my advice (cheesy as it may be) is to listen to your heart. Gah, I feel stupid just saying that, but it's true. Think about your emotions for each. Imagine yourself in a relationship with each, 6 months, 1 year, 5 years from now, if the case may be. Think about what you need and who can provide it for you. If all else fails, enjoy the single life for awhile.
 

madablak

New member
H: not fair to her if you don't feel the same she deserves the same amount of love back that she gives, not saying you can't give it to her but i think theres someone out there better for her plus shes just not you complete "fit"

A: ho ho ho is right, it didn't work out for a reason

L: for you to call her child "baggage" is disrespectful, to love her you will have to love her child... again it didn't work out for a reason

S: Sounds like you already have developed feelings for her and sometimes the "right" person can be right under your nose... if she feels the same I think it wouldn't hurt to try if you think you can still maintain a friendship if it does end badly

O: a woman you haven't met yet could be the one maybe you should try to find her
 
Top