What car is better? 2004 - 2005 Subaru WRX STI, Or 2000 - 2004 BMW e46 M3?

[bangit2]

Hey
im debating what car to buy and am stuck between these two. What one would be the better choice? Please list all pros and cons, thank you!

 

[AlexS]

Definitely the BMW.
BMW M3 is way faster than the suburu.
The BMW is better in every way. The only bad thing is it will cost more. Whoever says suburu only says it because they have one. The m3 is one of BMW's nicest cars.

 

[Trdlyota]

Of course a Subaru WRX STI!
- 286 hp 4 cylinder turbocharged engine (couldnt get better)
- AWD (amazing off road)
- Its sexier than a BMW.
- Very reliable unlike the BMW.
- Cheaper on insurance than the BMW.
- Friggin king of rally racing.
- Hah BMW's just suck.