What qualifies a question or answer to be deemed as an insulting rant?

F

Fairdo4all

New member
Joined
Jan 1, 2011
Messages
8
Reaction score
0
Points
1
Probably most questions are insulting rants to someone, particularly those concerning race or religion.
 
I wonder if referring to the government of China as a conspiracy for censorship puts an answer into the insulting category when a person does their reporting. At first I called China stupid & then I corrected myself in print. I was only attempting to keep my edits REAL.

Yes, I've appealed & I'm awaiting a reply from YA.
I'm still asking....
What qualifies a Q or A to be deemed an insulting rant?
 
Apparently, access to the "report" button is the only qualification necessary.
 
I think if somebody reports you and says in the space provided that its an insulting rant, then they treat it as such. If they say it is a derogatory comment regarding a specific race or gender, then that's the way they treat that as well.

Nothing is carved in stone. Get second account, and report your own answer as an insulting rant and see what happens, see if you get a violation.
 
According to the dictionary....rant is to talk in a loud, wild, extravagant way...rave. Usually when you see something that qualifies as a "rant" under the guidelines....it is one of those weird...all caps....loony things.

If what you are talking about actually was a violation....then nearly the entire R&S and politic sections would not exist....as 99 percent of the questions and answers would be in violation.
 
I try to stay away from insulting countries.Now one of my answers was reported because I insulted the section this member was a major contributer.The question was trolling and derogatory towards seniors.

I want to keep this section clean and enjoyable.The heat is on,the cats are sleeping.This is the environment I want to see here.Oh yes,wine and ginger ale are in the refrigerator as well.
 
In reality just about anyone here can claim a question to be insulting and a rant only because they can. I have never been successful in appealing a question or an answer being reported in violation and subsequently being deleted. There are people who will report anyone simply because they either do not like the person who is asking a question or the person who answered a question.
 
Yahoo! Answers isn't a soapbox to vent personal frustrations or rant about issues. We are a community of people with diverse beliefs, opinions, and backgrounds, so please be respectful and keep hateful and incendiary comments off Yahoo! Answers.
http://answers.yahoo.com/info/community_guidelines
 
They must have been insulted but that doesn't make them any less a blind dictatorship.
 
Hi, Dee, good to see you. Good luck with your appeal, but don't hold your breath. Personally, I don't think anything should be reported, but apparently anything can be considered an insult or a rant to some people with thin skins!
 
Good luck Dee. The last time I appealed Yahoo sent me an e-mail to copy and paste my information and send it to Tim Buck Tu, and yadda yadda ya. Then the next day, yesterday, they sent me a letter describing a few things I'm allowed to say in Y!A and a bunch of things I'm not allowed to say. So, I would say we Senior Citizens are definitely being targeted.
 
If someone reports it as a rant, it is a rant. Even if it is not. In my experience, appeals have never worked.
 
I ot reported for telling someone not to use viagara. Thats something you shouldn't have to use a stimulant for. If you do you have other problems that need to be addressed.

How can you get reported for telling someone the truth?
 
There is no perfect answer to this question because we are all from very different background each with different values, mentality and interpretation. Religion could be sacred or stupid to a believer or atheist, Democrats and Republicans always find each other wrong and stubborn. There is a very very fine line separating insulting rant and real reporting.
 
theres alotta that in here.... its up to us all to decide i guess this yahoo thing is stupid sometimes.......... and immature... everyone likes to vent i reckon.... JESUS..
 
i got reported for asking if one would care for a chili hot dog
maybe the people in chili were offended
usually anything political gets a rant report
anything that even sounds racist gets an insult report
i got deleted cause i used the words cracker jack
just post it we will read it before it gets deeweeded
great question
 
Back
Top